Salvatore Sanfilippo (@[email protected]) and Armin Ronacher (@[email protected]) both argue that #AI reimplementation of #copyleft libraries is fine. Their legal reasoning might be correct. That's not the point.
Legal and legitimate are different things—and both pieces quietly assume otherwise.
https://writings.hongminhee.org/2026/03/legal-vs-legitimate/
#GPL #LGPL #license #opensource #freesoftware
検索
It was in this spirit that #Linux distributions took off and the struggle to keep doing this fun hobby in a way that paid for itself became commonplace. Working at #RedHat, who was making ends meet with CD sales, coffee mugs, and the occasional support contract kept those good times going. When #proprietary #unix, by way of SCO, started getting lawsuit crazy, we found the #GPL really did stand up in court. #Groklaw was born, and IP law became something we all learned thanks to PJ, Webbink, etc.
Way back before Free Software, then Open Source were the phenomenon they have become, it was a very different world. Public domain, shareware, home brew computing... software licensing was alien to hobbyests. We relied on vague ownership concepts that didn't even have standing in international law. The #gpl, #free software, later #oss, this was all part of growing up, the result of many iterations of an attempt to control in some ways while sharing in others.
You want to talk about abusing the "spirit of the #GPL"? GPLv3 exists *because* of what Novell did with SUSE. #Linux
https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2007/01/linux-20070128/
You want to talk about abusing the "spirit of the #GPL"? GPLv3 exists *because* of what Novell did with SUSE. #Linux
https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2007/01/linux-20070128/
This Ask Noah Podcast Show episode (#RedHat Challenges with Bradley Kuhn) covers the contraversy pretty well.
Unfortunately, his guest conflates the #GPL w/all #OpenSource licenses.
Other than that, I recommend a listen.
#BSD #Linux
https://podcast.asknoahshow.com/345